"This is The End of the Line..."
~ Guest Questions by Doug Pascover. Have at 'em! ~
Pictures too small to see? Click 'em and watch 'em GROW.
Ornamental tile work at the
South Ferry Subway Station
"...Passengers May Exit Only From the First Five Cars of the Train."
??
Strange Instructions...
.
I rarely take New York's old #1 subway anywhere. From Downtown, there are several more efficient ways to ride the subway north into Manhattan: express trains, with fewer stops.
.
Still, one day, with nowhere in particular to go, I hopped onto an Uptown-bound #1 local train at its southernmost origin in Bowling Green/South Ferry... because, well, just look at that cool station house. (They were, and still are, referred to as control houses, where passengers come "under the control" of the
Metropolitan Transit Authority, or
MTA for short).
______________________________________

This is the South Ferry #1 subway train station. The Staten Island Ferry terminal is a few blocks beyond to the south, and Battery Park is to the right (west).

______________________________________
My train bounced along past a few stops: Rector Street, Fulton Street, Park Place. I got off a short way up the line at Chambers Street, stepped across the dusty gray concrete platform, and boarded a
Downtown-bound #1 to head back to South Ferry. I suppose I had a self-satisfied been-there-done-that grin on my face, the brief ride having satisfied my curiosity,
.
Or, so I thought.
.
As I approached my round-trip's starting point, the end of the line back at South Ferry Station, I heard a garbled announcement over the
train's scratchy public address system advising that, in order for passengers to get off the train, they would need to move to one of the first five of its ten cars.
.
What? I just couldn't have heard that right. How, umm, curious!
.
Curiously (of course), I looked around my subway car and, sure enough, eventually spotted an awkwardly worded placard confirming what I couldn't believe I'd heard, that passengers should hustle up to the front of the subway train in order to get off at South Ferry.
.
We were getting close to the station, and I wasn't even sure which car of the subway train I was in. What would happen if I didn't follow the strange instruction? Would I be turned 'round and dispatched back Uptown against my will? Would I be imprisoned for hours -- (gulp!) forever? -- alone in the musty hind cars of that old #1 train? Or, worse (gasp!), might I end up lost somewhere in Brooklyn?
.
I wasn't all
that curious, so I lurched from my seat on the moving train, grabbed a nearby pole, then the back of another seat, then a ceiling bar, next a hanging strap, then another pole, and, hand-over-hand in this manner, I clumsily lumbered my way forward. I've gotten pretty good at this "subway surfing" over the years, and can now handily pass from car to car in a rolling subway train, lurching through the creaky steel sliding doors at each end. I hardly ever lose my balance these days, and almost never canon-ball myself into some poor
somebody's hapless cup of (*
uggh*, sorry,
Neva, too bitter for me) Starbucks anymore. (Almost.)
.
It felt different this time, though, moving between the old cars as we rumbled into the South Ferry Station. I could see that we were making an unusually tight turn alongside its sharply curved platform, and the old
train's metallic banging, groaning, and whining, echoed and amplified within the walls of the narrow tunnel as I moved from car to car, jarred me more than usual.
.
Stepping off the train and onto the platform, I could see that the station was too short -- only long enough, in fact, to meet the doors of the
train's first five cars. Any passengers who remained in the last half of the train were still in the tunnel, looking down five or six feet at naked track. I wondered: might someone
asleep, or stupid, or drunk, be left behind back there? I looked up the tracks and spotted an
MTA conductor dutifully patrolling the back of the train to make sure it was empty. Those bureaucrats at the
MTA think of everything.
.
...For A Strange Old Train Station.
They broke ground for the New York Subway more than a century ago, way back in 1900. The first subway line, known at the time as the
Interboro Rapid Transit Company (or,
IRT), started service in 1904 carrying passengers between City Hall in Lower Manhattan and the Upper West Side. Eventually, to the delight of latter-day Yankees fans, the
IRT line was expanded all the way up into the Bronx.
.
Philadelphia-born MIT-trained architects
George Lewis Heins (1860–1907) and Christopher Grant LaFarge (1862–1938) won the contract to design the first phases of New York's subway system, and, perhaps given their prior experience designing
churches and municipal buildings, we shouldn't be too surprised by their Romanesque conception of its early stations, like the one at South Ferry. Built in 1905, it's one of only three of its kind left standing.
Another is partially boarded up on Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street in Brooklyn, (possibly) awaiting complete restoration; the
third is on
Verdi Square at 72
nd and Broadway, still busily greeting passengers traveling to and from
Pia Savage's posh (sorry, Pia, but its true) Upper West Side neighborhood.

This 1938 map shows the two-track terminal loop under South Ferry Station (dark red line at left, under Battery Park). The double lines to the right show the intersecting routing for the IRT's Lexington Avenue Line, which was built ca. World War I, and carry the 4/5 subway trains today.
.
Unique within the New York Subway System, the South Ferry Station is part of one of its earliest and most claustrophobic terminals. The single-track loop below South Ferry Station could accommodate passenger platforms no larger than the relatively tiny trains of its day. Over the years, to improve operating efficiency, New York's subways cars have become somewhat longer and are now strung together into ten-car trains -- much longer than were found in the system in 1905. Still, everything new works just fine everywhere throughout the enormous old New York Subway System -- except here at South Ferry. Hence, the bizarre passenger instructions.

.
Q. How do you cram a ten-car #1 train into the five-car-long South Ferry Station?
A 1 train pulls into South Ferry Station's weird curved platform in this YouTube video.
________________________________________
Personally, I think the South Ferry Station is quaint, cute, adorable, and I don't mind stumbling through a rattling train to get off there.
.
But, hey, evidently that's just me.
.
The MTA has a mind to fix it -- and money, and a plan. Happily, their hip new 21st century station will preserve that old early-20th-century South Ferry control house. Look for it standing atop a couple of parked ten-car subway trains, with passengers coming and going through every single one of their doors, by Christmas 2008.
.
It's gonna cost the MTA a couple hundred mill -- but, on the bright side, they'll be able to fire that conductor guy who rousts the drunks from the last five cars of #1 trains.
__________________________________
Q&A
Have you ever knowingly got onto a train just to ride it and, if so, how are you better than a common hobo?
If a train leaves Times Square with 10 20-foot cars, heading south at 30 miles per hour, how many drunks will be on board when it reaches South Ferry?
Should a New Yorker even consider using a word like "Adorable?" If so, under what circumstances?
Extra credit: is that odor you smell on a New York Subway platform while you're waiting for your train what you think it is?